I’ve tested a lot of so‑called “compact flagships,” but the Pixel 2 is one of the few that actually stayed in my pocket after the review period. Not because it’s excellent—far from it—but because it exposes exactly where Google nails the experience and where it still treats hardware like a side quest.
When I grabbed a refurb Pixel 2 for around $100 years after launch, it hit harder than it ever did at $900. At that price, its strengths feel like a win for consumers; at launch, they were a warning shot about where Google’s priorities really are.
A ‘Medium’ Pixel With Last‑Gen Looks
On paper, the Pixel 2 is the “small one,” but it’s not that small. At 145.7 x 69.7 x 7.8mm and 143g, it lives in the same physical territory as the iPhone X and Galaxy S8, while offering less display area thanks to those unapologetic bezels. You’re getting a 5-inch 16:9 Full HD (1080p) AMOLED, not the taller 18:9 panel from the XL.
This is peak 2017 design schizophrenia. The back has that unmistakable Pixel identity—the two-tone metal and glass panel—shrunk down a bit from the original Pixel. But flip it over and you’re greeted by forehead and chin so big you can almost measure them in centimeters. You’re not getting a smaller footprint than the S8 by much, and you’re losing real estate on the front.
Google at least gives you some character. Kinda Blue and Clearly White are exclusive to this smaller Pixel 2, while Just Black goes full incognito with a grainier, grippier finish. It’s understated in a way a lot of 2017 flagships weren’t. The fingerprint reader is perfectly placed on the back, but the power and volume keys stacked on the right side are an ergonomic miss—too easy to hit the volume rocker when you’re just trying to wake the phone.
Screen: Samsung Panel, Google Choices
The Pixel 2’s 5-inch Full HD AMOLED is sourced from Samsung, unlike the larger Pixel 2 XL’s LG-made panel, and that alone probably saved this phone’s reputation. No blue shift drama here. Color accuracy is excellent: average DeltaE is around 1.9, right up there with the iPhone X and Galaxy S8 (in Basic mode).
Brightness hits roughly 430 nits and stops. There’s no auto-boost mode outdoors like Samsung’s own phones, so you lose some punch in direct sunlight. It’s still readable, just not in the same league as Samsung’s current flagships for outdoor visibility. Infinite contrast and truly black blacks help a lot.
Google also avoided the washed-out, muted look that plagued the Pixel 2 XL at launch. Vivid or not, colors on the small Pixel 2 look lively without trashing accuracy. Corners are old-school sharp, no rounded-display aesthetic here, and the glass is mostly flat—no “3D” curve marketing like on the XL. Functionally, that’s fine. Visually, it underlines how conservative the front of this phone is.
Hardware: Snapdragon 835 Muscle, 2017 Headaches
Under the hood, the Pixel 2 runs the same Qualcomm Snapdragon 835 and 4GB of RAM as the XL and most 2017 Android flagships. Benchmarks put it right in line with other Snapdragon 835 phones: matching Galaxy S8 (Snapdragon) in Antutu and GeekBench, roughly tied with other top Androids in Basemark, and trailing Apple’s A11 iPhones by a clear margin.
Graphics performance is solid, and the Pixel 2 even beats its XL sibling in on‑screen tests thanks to the lower 1080p resolution. In practice, the phone feels snappy and consistent, not just in synthetic tests. This is still the reference experience for what Google wants Android to feel like.
Connectivity is flagship-grade for its era: Cat. 15 LTE (up to 800/75 Mbps depending on network), 3x carrier aggregation, 4×4 MIMO and 256-QAM support where carriers allow it. Bluetooth 5.0 + LE, dual-band Wi‑Fi 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac with 2×2 MIMO, NFC, GPS and GLONASS are all on board. There’s eSIM support for Project Fi alongside the usual nanoSIM.
Then come the anti-consumer choices. No microSD slot, full stop. The single nanoSIM tray on the left won’t take anything else. And Google brutally killed the 3.5mm jack this generation, forcing everything through USB‑C. Yes, there’s a USB‑C to 3.5mm dongle in the box. No, that doesn’t make up for the missing port.
There’s also no wireless charging. You do get IP67 water and dust resistance, an upgrade over the original Pixel, and wired charging via USB‑C and an 18W USB Power Delivery 2.0 brick—0 to 43% in 30 minutes, 0 to 100% in around 1 hour 50.
Battery is a 2,700mAh cell, smaller than the Galaxy S8’s 3,000mAh and similar to the iPhone X’s 2,716mAh. Endurance is quietly decent: about 11 hours of video playback and 12 hours of Wi‑Fi web browsing, weaker on 3G voice and standby. Overall rating around 75 hours translates to “no anxiety” for most days unless you live on cellular calls.
Active Edge—the squeeze-to-Assistant feature—is easier to trigger on this smaller frame than on the XL. The tech comes from HTC’s Edge Sense and works well in terms of detection, but Google locks it to Google Assistant. You can disable it entirely, but you can’t repurpose it. This is hardware designed to push a service, not help the user.
Stereo Speakers, Mono Audio, and Software That Finally Grew Up
The front-facing stereo speakers are one of the Pixel 2’s big wins. Despite the bezels being nearly as huge as the XL’s, the small Pixel 2 actually measures louder in testing—earning an “Excellent” loudness rating vs the XL’s “Good.” It’s not just volume; the sound stays clear and distortion-free even at max.
Where it stumbles is wired audio. Output to an external amp is above average in loudness with mostly excellent clarity, but channel separation is sub-par. Plug in headphones and the good news is there’s almost no degradation compared to the amp test. The bad news: the Pixel 2 XL is louder and better here, which makes the smaller phone feel a bit compromised, even if it’s not objectively bad.
On the software side, Android 8.0 Oreo (with 8.1 on deck) finally makes stock Android feel less like a developer preview and more like a complete OS. The Pixel 2’s launcher tweaks are sensible: Google Search bar moves down between app dock and nav buttons for reachability, the weather widget becomes a small at-a-glance strip that can show your next calendar event, and long-press on icons surfaces app shortcuts and app info.
The app drawer is reached by swipe, no dedicated button, and auto-sorts with a top row of frequently used apps plus alphabetical listing. There’s a search bar there too. Notifications and Quick Toggles get a cleaner two-stage shade: first pull for notifications + quick row, second pull to reveal full toggles and brightness.
Settings are finally condensed into sensible categories like “Network & Internet,” with integrated search for refugees from Samsung or Huawei skins. Pixel Imprint (fingerprint auth) is blazing fast and lets you pull down the notification shade with a swipe on the sensor. There’s an Always On display with notification icons and a double-tap-to-wake gesture.
Now Playing is the quietly brilliant trick: offline song recognition baked into the lockscreen and Ambient Display. The phone listens every ~60 seconds for music, checks an on-device, region-specific database of tens of thousands of songs (under 100MB), and shows the track name without sending audio to Google.
Instant Tethering and Wi‑Fi auto-on feel like half steps—features looking for a clear use case. Wi‑Fi scanning can flip Wi‑Fi on and auto-connect to known networks, but if you’re the kind of person who constantly manages radios, this just adds another layer of “smart” logic to fight.
Smart Storage is one of the few “cloud-first” ideas that’s actually user-friendly: once Google Photos has backed up your pictures and videos, the phone can auto-delete local copies older than 30/60/90 days or prompt you to clear them. For 64GB-only buyers, this is the difference between a usable phone and a constantly nagging storage warning.
Camera: Single Lens, Maximum Pressure on the Industry
This is where Google flexed and where the Pixel 2 still matters. The main camera is a 12MP sensor (1/2.6″ vs the original Pixel’s larger 1/2.3″), f/1.8 aperture, 1.4µm pixels, optical image stabilization, dual-pixel autofocus plus laser AF, and dual-LED flash. The front camera keeps 1.4µm pixels with an f/2.4 lens and leans heavily on Google’s HDR+ algorithms.
In good light, the Pixel 2’s photos are packed with detail and keep textures looking natural. If you pixel-peep, you’ll see more noise than on some competitors, even with HDR+ on, but that’s the trade-off for not nuking detail with aggressive noise reduction. Turn HDR+ off and noise goes up while dynamic range goes down; the fact that HDR+ is buried in settings by default (and always on) is intentional and correct.
Dynamic range is where Google pulls ahead. HDR+ aggressively preserves highlights—you’ll see more cloud detail, less clipping in bright areas compared to other flagships. Compared shots against iPhone 8 and Galaxy S8 show the Pixel 2 holding onto those tricky highlights more consistently. The “Enhanced” HDR+ mode goes harder on stacking and processing; in practice, leaving HDR+ on regular Auto is the sane default.
Panoramas are the weak spot: just ~1,800px tall, soft and under-detailed, even if stitching artifacts are rare. If panorama is your go-to mode, this isn’t your phone.
Low light is where HDR+ earns its keep. The Pixel 2 tones down bright light sources like streetlamps instead of blowing them out, which can look odd if you’re used to the usual overexposed blobs, but it’s actually more controlled. It consistently pulls meaningful detail from deep shadows while still retaining textures. Noise is visible, especially in uniform areas like night skies, but you get real information instead of plastic smudges.
Compared to Samsung’s noise suppression, Google lets the grain live to keep stucco and brick looking like stone instead of watercolor. Colors stay impressively accurate in the dark, one of the original HDR+ selling points.
Portrait mode is the big statement: Google does it with a single camera. Dual-pixel data builds a depth map, machine learning identifies the subject, then the phone applies variable blur to foreground and background. That’s theoretically better than a fixed blur from most dual-camera systems. In practice, it’s convincing more often than not. Stray hairs and messy edges still trip the algorithm, and the lack of a live depth preview is annoying.
Portrait mode works on objects too, not just faces. For unknown objects, it falls back more on dual-pixel depth instead of a learned model, but still produces decent separation. The selfie camera uses only ML (no dual-pixel depth) yet still delivers some of the best selfie portraits around at the time, with good exposure on faces and natural skin tones.
Video tops out at 4K 30fps, with 1080p at 60 or 30fps, and slow-motion at 1080p 120fps or 720p 240fps. No 4K 60 here while an “iRival” was already doing it. Bitrates are solid: ~41Mbps for 4K, ~33Mbps for 1080p60, and ~21.5Mbps for 1080p30. Audio, embarrassingly, is mono at 96kbps.
4K footage looks excellent: loads of detail, neutral processing, accurate color, and reliable white balance. 1080p30 holds up similarly well. 1080p60 is where Google drops the ball—the image is too soft compared to Galaxies and iPhones recording at the same resolution and framerate.
Stabilization is the secret weapon: OIS plus electronic stabilization all the way up to 4K. It does a very good job ironing out walking motion without introducing the warpy jello effect you sometimes see in heavy EIS systems. Panning is smooth, and the end result is video that looks more expensive than the phone’s price tag suggests.
Google Photos integration is the final piece: Pixel 2 buyers got unlimited full-resolution photo and video backup until January 2021, with the usual “High quality” 16MP/1080p unlimited tier afterward. The app itself is powerful: face and object search, auto “rediscover” memories, simple but effective editing tools, album and sharing controls, plus physical photo book ordering.
Consumer Reality Check: The Pixel 2’s Legacy
The Pixel 2 is the “reference Android phone” of its era, but also a blueprint for some of Google’s worst hardware instincts.
On the plus side, you’re getting:
– A camera that pushed every other OEM toward computational photography and smarter HDR.
– Stereo front-facing speakers that are actually loud and clean.
– A Samsung-made AMOLED with no glaring defects and class-leading color accuracy.
– Clean, fast Android with thoughtful touches like Now Playing, Smart Storage, and Always On.
– IP67 water resistance and decent battery life from a modest 2,700mAh cell.
On the negative side, you’re staring at:
– A design that wasted its footprint with big bezels while rivals delivered larger screens in the same size.
– No microSD, no headphone jack, no wireless charging, and a locked-down Active Edge.
– Mono video audio and soft 1080p60 in a phone priced as a full flagship at launch.
When someone picks up a refurb Pixel 2 for $100 and calls it “not that bad,” they’re accidentally summarizing Google’s entire hardware philosophy. For cheap, this phone is fantastic. At $900 launch pricing with a 6‑month-feeling flagship lifespan, it was Google testing how much compromise Android fans would tolerate for a top-tier camera and clean OS.
Did consumers win? Sort of. The industry copied the worst parts—headphone jack removal, sealed storage, aggressive assistant pushes—while still chasing the Pixel’s camera output. The Pixel 2 “Medium” survived better than its XL twin because the screen didn’t implode in controversy, but they both told the same story: Google understood software and imaging deeply, and treated hardware like a cost center to be minimized.
If you care about ownership, longevity, and actual user control, the Pixel 2 is a brilliant cautionary tale wrapped around a genuinely great camera.
Have thoughts on this? Share them in the comments.